- 1959 – Dorothy Woodward*
- 1960 – Louise Roberts*
- 1961 – Betty Schmidt*
- 1962 – Dorothy Putnam
- 1963 – Mary Lou Eitzman*
- 1964 – Rhalda Prystowsky
- 1965 – Jean Smith
- 1966 – Erlene Wheat
- 1967 – Shirley Williams
- 1968 – Margaret Enneking*
- 1969 – Audrey Schiebler*
- 1970 – Eleanor (Kaufman) Schmidt
- 1971 – Anne Shands
- 1972 – Carol Crevasse
- 1973 – Alice Talbert
- 1974 – Judy Banks
- 1975 – Tia (King) Hall
- 1976 – Martha Wittig
- 1977 – Joyce Rhoton
- 1978 – Margery Pierson
- 1979 – Carol Kem
- 1980 – Barbara Harty
- 1981 – Barbara Dockery
- 1982 – Barbara Agee*
- 1983 – Cindy Stern
- 1984 – Mary Lou Weber
- 1985 – Betty Petty
- 1986 – Jenny Streiff
- 1987 – Kate Wilkinson
- 1988 – Kristine Gallagher
- 1989 – Jo Ella Harris
- 1990 – Wanda Boyce*
- 1991 – Susan Rout
- 1992 – Chris Randall*
- 1993 – Mary Staab*
- 1994 – Kathy Mladinich
- 1995 & 1996 – Lynn Newman
- 1997 & 1998 – Sandy Berger
- 1999 & 2000 – Michelle Donnelly
- 2001 & 2002 – Twana Richard
- 2003 & 2004 – Christine Riggs
- 2005 & 2006 – Lynn Newman
- 2007 & 2008 – Kathryn Seagle
- 2009 & 2010 – Janice Nelson
- 2011 & 2012 – Diane Malphurs*
- 2013 & 2014 – Lynda Bucciarelli
- 2015 & 2016 – Linda Allegra
- 2017 & 2018 – Diane Yang
- 2019 & 2020 – Christine Riggs
*deceased